Friday 11 September 2015, Joel Cohen

Migration needs a moral not a bureaucratic response

We need to look beyond the current crisis to ask bigger questions about immigration.

Cast your mind back a few months and you’ll remember our General Election where ‘Full Britannia’ besieged by Calais’ poor, tired and hungry was thought such a galvanizing stance that mug-ladden Labour tried to fend off UKIP’s advance with beefed-up border controls.

Today, confronted with the harsh realities of this policy, and shamed by Germany’s open arms towards migrants, the mood in Britain is very different. Now more than ever, we must start a new debate on how Britain should react to the problems of migration aside from the economics of taking people in.

In a small discussion at the Overseas Development Institute last night, Stephen Hale, chief executive of Refugee Action, rightly urged the audience to look forward to solutions for a crisis that’s been four years in the making rather than assigning blame for past (in)actions. The debate itself raised many questions over our government’s recent change of heart: what good are new measures that fail to match the scale of the problem? Does opening the door to Syrian migrants create a two-tiered response to the migration crisis? And how are we helping if our door is open, but the path that leads to it continues to remain dangerous?

To answer these questions, we need a clear understanding of what our moral duty is to refugees and migrants - no matter which you call them. But members of the UN Security Council remains divided or are unwilling to choose a course of action; the many committees and commissions of the EU have failed to make good on the promise of international cooperation; and our government remains smugly satisfied with arms-length military escapades and continues to do 0.7 per cent of the right thing following its GDP commitments to overseas-development aid. Whatever else, a clear picture is emerging that effective answers won’t come from these lazy leviathans of international life.

Whether you are in favour of open borders or are just sympathetic to the plight of those on the move, we must remember to look beyond the humanitarian tragedies of the current crisis and start arguing over the meaty moral questions at the heart of our response: what duties do we have to the outside world and how should we act on them?

Battle of Ideas satellite event

Is Britain full?, Wednesday 30 September, 19.00 - 20.30, The House of St Barnabas, 1 Greek St, London W1D 4NQ



Battle of Ideas 2015

9:30am, Saturday 17 October 2015, The Barbican, Silk St, London EC2Y 8DS

what's happening next

Can we cancel ‘cancel culture’?

Tuesday 11 August, 7pm (UK time), online, via Zoom